Catholic Apologetics Online

Catholic Apologetics in Question & Answer Form

Persecution

1015. I was surprised by your justification of the Inquisition.

I justified it as a tribunal set up to discipline unworthy members of the Church and traitors against the state. But I pointed out that I did not justify abuses of power by some of its officials.

1016. Torture was one of its main activities for the treatment of both state offenders and heretics.

Torture was not one of its main activities. Nor was corporal punishment employed as a penalty of heresy as such. Insofar as a heretic was also an offender against the state, he was subject to state penalties. I cannot go more deeply into this question now, but it is evident that you are not fully informed on the subject of the Inquisition and its historical setting.

1017. The clerics on the Inquisition knew that Christ never intended heretics to be treated like that.

It is certain that the treatment of heresy was not as you imagine it to have been. But granting, for the sake of argument, that the clerics did behave in an unchristian way, the fact remains that their conduct was not in accordance with their Catholic religion, and they, therefore, deserve censure, not the Church they unworthily represented in such conduct.

1018. In one of your replies you said in effect that the Catholic Church had never taken life.

Correct.

NEXT TOPIC »